Why I’m an Ex-Hindu
Hinduism is one of the world’s oldest religions, with a rich cultural, philosophical, and artistic heritage. Its art, music, festivals, and traditions have influenced civilizations for thousands of years. However, when examined critically, both its theology and social practices present logical inconsistencies, moral contradictions, and patterns of systemic exploitation. This reflection is intended to explain why leaving Hinduism became necessary while still recognizing its cultural significance.
1. Gods with Multiple Limbs and Heads
Hindu deities are often depicted with multiple arms, heads, or other extraordinary features:
Vishnu has four arms, each holding a different symbolic object.
Shiva is depicted with five heads, sometimes multiple forms, and a third eye.
Durga has ten arms, each holding weapons for battle.
While these representations are symbolic, they raise logical questions:
- If gods are omnipotent, why do they need extra limbs or heads to perform tasks?
- Why can’t an all-powerful being accomplish everything with a single form?
- These forms make gods appear more like characters in a story than beings of moral and spiritual authority.
Example:
Shiva’s third eye is described as capable of destroying the universe. If Shiva is omnipotent, why is there risk in using it? The narrative introduces arbitrary limitations rather than conveying consistent divine logic.
2. Sexual Behavior and Questionable Morality
Many myths depict gods engaging in sexual acts or morally questionable behavior:
Krishna is portrayed as having sexual relations with multiple gopis, which is celebrated as divine play.
Shiva and Parvati’s stories include secretive sexual trials, sometimes involving deception or testing human fidelity.
The moral concern is clear:
- Gods are supposed to serve as moral exemplars. Portraying them engaging in acts considered immoral for humans introduces a contradiction in ethical guidance.
- These stories encourage reverence for behaviors that, in human society, would be condemned.
3. Exploitation and Disrespect of Women
Hinduism’s mythology and historical practices include patterns of systemic disrespect and exploitation of women, including the following:
A. Worship Rituals Involving Extreme Subservience
Rituals such as washing a guru’s or deity’s feet, drinking the water used to wash them, or performing excessive acts of servitude were often enforced on women.
These practices implied complete submission, reducing the woman’s agency and dignity in the name of religious obedience.
B. Devdasi System
Women were dedicated to temples as devdasis, serving in rituals that included sexual exploitation.
This system institutionalized the exploitation of women, conflating religious duty with coerced sexual access.
Though culturally justified as sacred service, it systematically denied women autonomy and consent.
C. Niyog and Forced Surrogacy Practices
Historical practices like niyog allowed a man to impregnate a woman other than his wife if the wife was infertile, often with little regard for the woman’s consent.
Children were considered the property of the husband or lineage, and women’s emotional and physical well-being were secondary.
Such practices treated women as instruments for reproduction rather than individuals with rights and dignity.
D. Treatment of Widows
Widows were often denied remarriage, isolated, or forced into austerity for the rest of their lives.
Social and religious customs placed blame on widows for family misfortune, reflecting systemic gender inequality.
E. Dowry and Property Discrimination
In many regions, women were deprived of inheritance and property rights.
Marriage often transferred ownership and control from the woman to her husband’s family, reinforcing economic dependence.
4. Miracles and Supernatural Claims
Hindu scriptures frequently describe miraculous events:
Krishna lifting the Govardhan Hill.
Hanuman flying across oceans.
Ganesha’s head being replaced with that of an elephant.
These miracles are often presented as historical truths. Critical concerns include:
- Believing in miracles requires suspension of reason and empirical observation.
- Miracles are selectively applied, raising questions about divine purpose and justice.
5. Gods Experiencing Mortality and Suffering
Many avatars of Hindu gods are described as dying, being wounded, or facing human-like struggles:
Krishna is killed by a hunter’s arrow.
Rama suffers exile, grief, and loss of family members.
Shiva endures cosmic battles and emotional turmoil.
This creates logical contradictions:
- If gods are eternal and omnipotent, why are they vulnerable?
- These stories depict divine beings as mortal in ways that conflict with the principle of omnipotence.
6. Contradictory Texts and Teachings
Hinduism has no single authoritative scripture. Its vast corpus includes:
Vedas and Upanishads
Puranas
Mahabharata and Ramayana
Regional scriptures and commentaries
Issues arising from this multiplicity include:
- Conflicting guidance on morality, marriage, violence, and social behavior.
- Difficulty discerning universal principles of ethical conduct.
- Inconsistent instructions on rituals, worship, and devotion.
Example:
One text may glorify polygamy; another glorifies chastity and sexual restraint.
One text justifies violence; another preaches non-violence.
7. Arbitrary and Burdensome Worship Rules
Worship practices vary significantly depending on the deity, region, or tradition.
Women were often required to perform elaborate rituals involving fasting, pilgrimages, or acts of servitude.
Failure to observe rituals correctly was thought to bring divine displeasure or misfortune.
These rules were:
- Arbitrary, lacking consistent rationale.
- Emotionally and physically taxing, especially on women who bore the majority of ritual responsibility.
8. Overcomplicated Theology
Hindu theology involves hundreds of gods, thousands of avatars, and innumerable rituals.
- Keeping track of all deities, their forms, stories, and proper worship methods is overwhelming.
- Lack of centralized authority leads to divergent interpretations and confusion.
Implication:
Religious adherence requires memorization and ritual performance rather than understanding or internalized ethical reflection.
9. Moral Inconsistencies in Myths
Gods perform acts that are both morally exemplary and morally questionable.
Examples include Krishna killing Kamsa and Rama killing Ravana.
The criteria for justified action vary, leading to confusion regarding universal ethical principles.
10. Gendered Social Practices and Exploitation
In addition to mythology, Hinduism’s historical social practices systematically disadvantaged women:
- Devdasi Exploitation: Women dedicated to temples were coerced into sexual service while framed as sacred duty.
- Niyog or Surrogate Practices: Women’s bodies were treated as tools for lineage continuation, often without consent.
- Widowhood Restrictions: Widows were socially ostracized, prohibited from remarriage, and forced into austerity.
- Dowry and Property Discrimination: Women were denied inheritance and economic autonomy.
- Ritualized Submission: Washing guru’s feet, drinking foot water, or performing subservient acts reinforced gender hierarchy.
These practices reveal a systemic lack of respect for women’s autonomy and dignity, often justified through religious interpretation.
11. Cultural Appreciation Without Belief
While Hindu culture has historical and artistic value, many modern festivals can have negative social consequences:
- Economic and Social Impact: Festivals like Diwali, Holi, and Navratri involve massive spending on fireworks, parties, and events, often costing families millions of dollars collectively.
- Exposure to Immoral Behavior: During these festivals, especially in hotels, party venues, or unsupervised gatherings, teenagers and young adults are sometimes exposed to alcohol, drugs, and sexual activity. Reports from multiple cities indicate that some young people engage in adultery, casual sex, or other morally irresponsible behavior during festival celebrations.
- Moral Concerns for Children: The festival environment may normalize early sexual activity, excessive drinking, and reckless behavior, undermining ethical values and family guidance.
This shows that while cultural and artistic aspects of Hinduism are valuable, the modern practice of festivals can encourage immoral behavior among youth, especially if not guided responsibly. Recognizing this allows one to appreciate culture without endorsing harmful practices.
12. Summary of Reasons for Leaving Hinduism
- Gods with multiple limbs and heads, inconsistent with omnipotence.
- Sexualized behavior and adultery of gods.
- Miracles defying logic and reason.
- Mortality and suffering of supposedly eternal beings.
- Contradictory scriptures and inconsistent moral guidance.
- Arbitrary, burdensome worship rules.
- Overcomplicated theology and ritual expectations.
- Exploitative practices against women, including Devdasi system, Niyog, widow restrictions, dowry, and ritualized submission.
- Lack of clear, universal ethical principles.
13. Conclusion
Leaving Hinduism was not a rejection of culture, art, or philosophy. It was motivated by, The need for logical consistency in theology, The demand for moral clarity and ethical universality, The recognition that social practices historically exploited and disrespected women.
Exiting Hinduism allows one to:
Preserve respect for cultural heritage, Reject illogical narratives, immoral behaviors, and exploitative practices, Seek a worldview based on reason, ethics, and dignity for all human beings, In conclusion, Hinduism offers valuable cultural and philosophical insights, but its mythology, moral inconsistencies, and treatment of women make adherence incompatible with a rational, ethical life. This is why leaving Hinduism became necessary while still allowing the preservation of respect for its historical and cultural contributions.
Click the ad to read the content.
Open Telegram